By David Swanson
“Lying to Ourselves: Dishonesty in the Army Profession” is the title of a new paper by Leonard Wong and Stephen Gerras of the U.S. Army’s Strategic Studies Institute. Its thesis: the U.S. Army is full of liars who habitually lie as part of a lying culture that has internalized and normalized lying to the point of unrecognizability.
Finally a claim from the Army I’m prepared to take seriously!
But the authors aren’t interested in the Army’s lying press releases or lying Congressional testimony or lying sound bytes promoting each new war, predicting imminent success, and identifying each dead adult or child as an evildoer. In fact, it seems pretty clear that the authors are in fact lying to themselves about the nature of the Army’s lying.
To hear them tell it, the Army’s lying problem could be the same as in any other institution. They don’t compare the Army to any other institutions, except to say that their analysis applies to the whole U.S. military, and the implication is that other institutions do not have it so bad. But the root of the problem, as they see it, is impossible demands placed on members of the military. To meet the impossible demands, people lie. And this — not the mission of mass murder — makes them “ethically numb.”
Members of the Army, we’re told, engage in “ethical fading,” using euphemisms and obscure phrases to disguise the immorality of what they are doing — namely overstating the supplies shipped or understating their own weight or some other “ethical” matter, not burning families to death in their homes with million-dollar missiles.
All of this unethicalness, the authors maintain, can create hypocritical leaders who hide billions in the “Overseas Contingency Operations” slush fund or cover up sex scandals. Really? Immorality enters an institution of mass murder that routinely deceives the public and much of the government from the bottom up? Excessive demands on troops creates a culture of lying than infects the good generals at the top? Are you kidding me? No, of course you aren’t. You’re lying to yourselves.
Soldiers realize pretty quickly that they’re not benefitting the people of Iraq or Afghanistan or whatever country they’re terrorizing. They understand that the entire mission is a lie. They learn to lie about their own actions, to plant “drop weapons,” to invent justifications, to provide support for their commanders’ efforts to believe their own lies.
Matthew Hoh, a State Department whistleblower, said today: “The culture of lying that is endemic and systemic in the Army, as found by researchers with the Army War College, finds its expression in America’s pointless wars, a one trillion dollar-a-year, pork-filled and inauditable national security budget, chronic veteran suicides, an expanded and more globally robust international terrorist movement, and untold suffering of millions of people and political chaos throughout the Greater Middle East perpetuated by our war policies.
“However, listening to our military leaders, and the politicians who adore and deify them rather than oversee them, America’s wars and its military have been a great patriotic success. This report is not a surprise for those of us who have worn the uniform, nor should it be surprising to those who have watched and paid attention with a modicum of critical and independent thought to our wars these past thirteen plus years. The wars are failures, but careers must prosper, budgets must increase and popular narratives and myths of American military success must endure, so the culture of lying becomes a necessity for our Army at a great physical, mental and moral cost to our Nation.”
In other words, War Is A Lie.
They wrote it that way so someone, anyone, would actually read it and not toss it for being commie trash. if a full accounting – it gets burned. baby steps, they seem to say.
Dear Mr. Swanson,
Please excuse the grammar and spelling mistakes.
MY NAME IS JOHN VICTOR, > I WAS IN B COMPANY 1/6 198TH LIB. B > COMPANY. > ARRIVED JULY 69 AND DEPARTED MAY 70. > I RAN THE 81 MM MORTAR THAT WE CARRIED WITH US IN THE FIELD. > WE SPENT 2-3 MONTHS IN THE FIELD THEN GOT A 3 DAY BREAK. > IF ANYONE REMEMBERS ME, PLEASE CONTACT ME. firstname.lastname@example.org > THANKS. > JOHN VICTOR > PS: JAN 10,1970 WE WERE HIT WITH OUR OWN artllery at night and the good man I was training James Lega was killed instantly next to me.
This has gone on for so long and so pervasively that I don’t understand why people don’t get it.My family thinks I am a little crazy (and I am) because I don’t get angry anymore ,I just say they are lying.
Two more points.
Why are military officers (I was offered OCS and a direct commission)ever fired or demoted for major mistakes like disbanding the Iraqi police force or building a forward base in Afghanistan below threexmountains.
Don’t these officers ever go out to the field and look? I never saw an officer above captain in the field. The rest were getting 3 hots and a bed every night.
Finally,why are they hesitant to stop the the raping and harassment of women. I wouldn’t let my daughter go to any of the acadamies. I think that they don’t have the balls to do it.I will tell you that if I was in charge of a unit that the rapist would not make it to court . I would shoot him.
Thank you for your article.